Viet Nam Adoption Blog

05/24/07

“You Don’t Hug Adopted Kids.”

Posted by : Rebecca in Viet Nam Adoption Blog at 06:16 pm , 363 words, 103 views  
Categories: Parenting
This was the statement that came out of Ella’s pediatrician’s mouth at our most recent office visit. It was said to the physician’s assistant student who is training with our doctor. Ella’s examination with the doctor was over and she was reaching towards this student. She really wanted to get at the blinds covering the window behind her, but I said “Oh, do you want a hug?” and the student smiled, to which our doctor replied “You don’t hug adopted kids.” Huh.

I am fully aware about the importance of attachment and I know that this doctor did not think we should let anyone hold Ella when we first got home, but I was a little taken aback by her comment. She said it lightly and kind of laughed it off a bit, but it was still a little strange at the moment. We’ve been home about seven months and she (the doctor) does nothing but make positive comments about Ella’s attachment with her mom and dad, her intelligence and her progress. Clearly, she is doing fine, and if she wanted to hug this lady….I wouldn’t have batted an eyelash. If she reached up to her, said “mama” and nuzzled into her neck, then I would have been concerned. And she really did only want the adjustment stick to the blinds anyway.

SPONSOR
Click Here for More Information

I’m going to chalk it all up to the fact that the doctor is trying to educate the student about how to work with internationally adopted kids, and the importance of letting them bond with mom and dad first and foremost before anyone else. But I have to hope that she’s not teaching hard and fast rules about adopted kids, because not all rules apply to all kids. And some parents choose to keep their new baby to themselves and some do not. I hope that this physician’s assistant in training has enough common sense to realize what a parent has chosen to do in regards to their child and to respect their choices-whatever they may be.




Related Links:
How to Teach Your Family About Attachment
Choosing a Pediatrician

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Twins [Member] Email
We just recently had an issue with our physican's assistant. I wonder if there is better training, or information that can be given to our medical professional.
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 20:11
Comment from: Faith Allen [Member] Email · http://hoping.adoptionblogs.com/
I have never heard that before. (Of course, I did adopt domestically.) That's bizarre to me that a doctor would say that, especially knowing that you did not just adopt her.

- Faith
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 20:13
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
Frankly, from where I sit, I'll take that ped any time. Better that she is aware of those issues and errs on the side of promoting the parents as the "givers of hugs", instead of being clueless and not having the sense to even assess your daughter's attachment to you when you visit. She knows what many parents DON'T know and there are probably lots of kids who get their warm fuzzies from an unsuspecting pediatrician, thereby enabling the child to go for another marathon stint at home avoiding all contact with their family members.

I understand why you reacted the way you did, but truly, you seem to me to have found a great pediatrician. I wish a whole lot more of them had a clue about attachment issues in adoptees.
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 21:11
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
Seemed extreme and useful at the same time, like they GET it, but are a bit too orthodox. I reckon it depends on the parents and how secure the child's attachment to them is..
But the way it's worded sounds like "Don't ever hug adopted children EVER." which is alarming.
PermalinkPermalink 05/25/07 @ 09:59
Comment from: Rebecca [Member] Email · http://vietnam.adoptionblogs.com
Chromesthesia - I think you hit the nail on the head as to my reaction. I felt it was 'Extreme and useful at the same time'.

I totally agree that it's wonderful that she's aware about adopted kids and their need to bond and attach to mom and dad only at first, but she also knows us and Ella. We've been seeing her for about 7 months now and she's always pleased with her attachment to us. But I really think she was saying it as more of a means to educate the student than a comment on our family.

Nancy, I wish all doctors were more educated about adoption and attachment too. I also wish all adoptive parents would take it upon themselves to get educated so they could correct their doctor when they go to cuddle and pick up their new baby!

Twins, here is an article that touches on the basics of attachment: http://attachment.adoption.com/bonding/foundations-of-attachment.html Maybe it would be helpful to pass along at the doctor's office when/if you choose to discuss it with them.

Thanks all for posting!
Rebecca
PermalinkPermalink 05/25/07 @ 17:25
Comment from: littlerivermom [Member] Email
I wonder if the doc couldn't have handled it better by teling the student before walking in to see you that some adopted children have bonding issues and that she needs to be aware of that. Since she knows that your daughter doesn't have that problem, there should have been nothing said in that moment. That's just what I think.
PermalinkPermalink 05/27/07 @ 15:47
Comment from: Rebecca [Member] Email · http://vietnam.adoptionblogs.com
That's a wonderful point littlerivermom - it certainly could/should have been handled differently.
thanks for posting!
Rebecca
PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 20:04
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Nationwide
 

Misc

Subscribe to Viet Nam Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Julie
  • Guest Users: 179